Alternating aperture phase shift masks (AAPSM) continue to offer high contrast imaging for 65nm half-pitch using conventional 193nm illumination. The transition to high NA lithography systems including immersion lithography, and the ever-decreasing feature sizes have made the topography of the photomask a significant issue in the final resist image. Therefore, the influence of the alternating phase shift depth, the trench profile, and the critical dimension control through variable feature width must be considered and understood for optimized wafer imaging.
This paper will examine the impact on imaging based on three photomasks, each employing different quartz etch chemistries. The three methods used to define the well structures include two all dry and a partial wet etch approach. As the photomask features continue to decrease, slight changes in the quartz etched trench profile and depth can severely affect the wafer prints, as the effective 180 degree phase shift for imaging is not achieved. In this work we correlate the imaging performance through pitch to a systematic evaluation of the photomask topography using complementary photomask metrology techniques.
The actual depth and profile of the structures is obtained on a FEI Stylus nano-profilometer (SNP-XT) and from destructive cross sections. The CD linearity is measured on a top-down reticle CD SEM (KLA 8100XR). Based on photomask metrology data, rigorous electro-magnetic field (EMF) simulations of the various topographic profiles are performed. As a first printing performance estimate the photomasks are evaluated on a Zeiss AIMSfab193. Comparisons between the different evaluations will be made against wafer prints, obtained on an ASML PAS5500/1100 ArF scanner working with a 0.75NA projection lens.
This study will lead to an understanding of the impact of possible limitations of the current quartz etching processes on the imaging performance of alternating phase-shift masks for 65nm half-pitch.
A NIST traceable phase1 shift standard has been designed, fabricated, and tested on three phase shift measurement tools using different wavelengths. By using the fundamentals of NIST traceable step height, quartz index, and the understanding of the illumination optics of the Lasertec phase metrology tool, a phase standard has been created which can be used to calibrate Lasertec phase metrology tools. The pattern that is used is compatible with the recommended best practices for calibrating and measuring step heights and phase on the Lasertec tools. The mask is made with multiple depths. The three mask depths allow for the mask to be calibrated to three NIST traceable depth heights. This was done using the FEI SNP XT depth metrology tool. Since the mask format is mask based (6x250 Cr on quartz), it can be easily used on mask manufacturing metrology systems. The depths are targeted at the 180-degree phase shift for 157nm, 193nm, and 248nm lithography. The mask can be used to set targets and check the linearity of the phase metrology tools. The patterns are compatible with AFM and Profilometer depth metrology tools as well as multiple Lasertec spot sizes and shearing distances. The quartz depths are fabricated using a wet quartz etch process. The wet etch minimizes the quartz roughness and removes that error source from the metrology. The pattern is also arrayed so that multiple sites can be used to confirm the metrology and the prime measurement site could be changed if there was a suspicion of pattern damage or contamination.
In order to meet stringent mask CD uniformity requirements, mask makers require a high precision CD metrology tool. According to the 2003 revision of the International Technology Roadmap for Semiconductors, there are no known solutions for sub-nanometer CD precision requirements. Furthermore, ITRS lists non-destructive, production worthy mask level microscopy for CD measurement for 3D structures as one of the five difficult challenges for 2009 and beyond. This paper focuses on the recent development successes of a scanning force based microscopy platform (Stylus NanoProfilometry, SNP). Innovative scanning strategies are discussed that enable high throughput, sub nanometer CD precision on advanced mask structures. Advancements in tip technology are also highlighted with metrology data presented on re-entrant alternating aperture phase shift mask features.
The effort to produce perfect dimension repairs of quartz bump defects on Alternating-Aperture Phase Shift Masks (AAPSM) has been brought to a new level with process developments to meet 90 nm technology node specifications. Decreasing photomask line and space dimensions pushes performance requirements for a mask repair system in terms of fine control in difficult to access structures on the mask surface. New repair strategies using a recently improved focused ion beam mask repair system for different defect types are discussed, along with their relative effectiveness. These strategies are then applied to the repair of full height extension and bridging defects in a line and space array. The role of quartz topography and its optical effects, Cr edge bias, and the combination of both strategies in a quartz bump repair are discussed. Additionally, effective process controls in repair are also discussed, along with analysis of metrology data received from a stylus nano-profilometer (SNP) system, and their relationship to potential imaging on the wafer by examination of AIMS data at a high numerical aperture. Several possible mask repair process flows are also reviewed in light of this work.
As advanced photolithography extends the ability to print feature sizes below the 100 nm technology node, various reticle enhancement techniques (RET) are being employed to improve resolution. An example of RET is the alternating phase shift mask (APSM), which currently challenges the ability of conventional repair techniques to repair even the most basic reticle defect. The phase shifting quartz bump is one defect type critical to the performance of APSM technology masks. These defects on the APSM reticle are caused by imperfections in the resist image during processing, resulting in a localized under or over etch of the quartz substrate. The integrated application of gas assisted etch (GAE), focused ion beam (FIB) reticle repair, and atomic force microscopy (AFM), provides a comprehensive solution for advanced reticle defect repair and characterization. Ion beam repair offers superior accuracy and precision for removal without significant damage to the underlying or adjacent quartz. The AFM technique provides quantitative measurement of 3D structures, including those associated with alternating phase shifters etched into quartz as well as embedded shifters. In the work presented in this paper, quartz bump defects were pre-scanned on an AFM tool and proprietary software algorithms were used to generate defect image and height map files for transfer to the FIB reticle repair tool via a network connection. The FIB tool then used these files to selectively control the ion dose during the corresponding quartz defect repair. A 193 nm APSM phase shift photomask with programmed defects in 400 nm line and space pattern was repaired using an FEI Stylus NanoProfilometer (SNP) and a FEI Accura 850 focus ion beam (FIB) tool. Using the APSM FIB repair method, the transmittance evaluated from 193 nm AIMS at the repair area was more than 90% without post-processing.
As advanced photolithography extends the ability to print feature sizes below the 100 nm technology node, various reticle enhancement techniques (RET) are being employed to improve resolution. An example of RET is the alternating phase shift mask (APSM), which currently challenges the ability of conventional repair techniques to repair even the most basic reticle defect. The phase shifting quartz bump is one defect type critical to the performance of APSM technology masks. These defects on the APSM reticle are caused by imperfections in the resist image during processing, resulting in a localized under or over etch of the quartz substrate. The integrated application of gas assisted etch (GAE), focused ion beam (FIB) reticle repair, and atomic force microscopy (AFM), provide a comprehensive solution for advanced reticle defect repair and characterization. Ion beam repair offers superior accuracy and precision for removal without significant damage to the underlying or adjacent quartz. The AFM technique provides quantitative measurement of 3D structures, including those associated with alternating phase shifters etched into quartz as well as embedded shifters. In the work presented in this paper, quartz bum defects were pre-scanned on an AFM tool and proprietary software algorithms were used to generate defect image and height map files for transfer to the FIB reticle repair tool via a network connection. The FIB tool then used these files to control selectively the ion dose during the corresponding quartz defect repair. A 193 nm APSM phase shift photomask with programmed defects in 400 nm line and space pattern was repaired using an FEI Stylus NanoProfilometer (SNP) and a FEI Accura 850 focus ion beam (FIB) tool. Using the APSM FIB repair method, the transmittance evaluated from 193 nm AIMS at the repair area was more than 90% without post-processing.
In this paper we describe the development of a chrome dry etch process on a new type of mask etch tool. One crucial goal was to minimize the CD etch bias. To meet this goal, a procedure for the direct characterization of CD etch bias was developed. The common methods for measuring the CD etch bias as resist-to-chrome CD difference, such as confocal optical microscope or SEM measurement, only give correct results, if the sidewalls are identical to the calibration standard. This is normally not the case as, due to the differing step height of resist and chrome, and the fact that during process development, in particular, the sidewall shapes and angles can vary significantly. Thus, it is very important to use a CD measurement method which takes the sidewall shapes (slope, foot) into account. One novel method is the use of a Scanning Nano Profiler (SNP) which was derived from the AFM principle. In contrast to AFM the use of a special high aspect ratio tip with 90° sidewall angle, in combination with pixelwise scanning of the substrate surface, provides information about the true sidewall shape and CD.
As photomask critical dimensions extend well into the submicron range, optical measurement techniques are approaching the end of their useful life. While offering advantages of being nondestructive, relatively fast, and very precise, optical measurement tools may have accuracy problems due to diffraction. Linearity between measured and actual values is typically lost due to interference, resonance, and shadowing effects even before the diffraction limit is reached. In addition, standards for submicron features do not exist for optical tools. These limitations have given rise to using a Scanning Electron Microscope (SEM) for reticle dimension measurement. Another complication is that no NIST standard exists for chromium photomask dimensions. A CD SEM must therefore be calibrated to some other trusted standard or measurement method. A Stylus NanoProfilometer (SNP) has better inherent resolution than a SEM and was chosen as the standard measurement instrument for both CD SEM and optical tool metrology. This paper describes the cross-calibration of the Leica LWM-250 (white light) optical metrology tool and the KLA-Tencor 8100XP-R CD SEM, with reference to a Surface Interface SNP9000. The primary motivation was to define the usable ranges of both SEM and optical CD measurement systems, allowing for flexible implementation into a photomask manufacturing environment.
Access to the requested content is limited to institutions that have purchased or subscribe to SPIE eBooks.
You are receiving this notice because your organization may not have SPIE eBooks access.*
*Shibboleth/Open Athens users─please
sign in
to access your institution's subscriptions.
To obtain this item, you may purchase the complete book in print or electronic format on
SPIE.org.
INSTITUTIONAL Select your institution to access the SPIE Digital Library.
PERSONAL Sign in with your SPIE account to access your personal subscriptions or to use specific features such as save to my library, sign up for alerts, save searches, etc.